For final publication, the manuscript should be
|accepted as is|
|accepted subject to technical corrections|
|accepted subject to minor revisions|
|reconsidered after major revisions|
Were a revised manuscript to be sent for another round of reviews:
|I would be willing to review the revised manuscript.|
|I would not be willing to review the revised manuscript.|
|Suggestions for revision or reasons for rejection |
|I have only a few minor comments; if these are taken into account, the publication can be published:|
Page 7 Line 174: "vertically integrated liquid(VIL)"
If you show an figure, something should be said about it in the text (otherwise you can skip the figure).
Page 7 Line 173ff: Figure shows...
Text suggestion (with some deletions):
"Figure 2 shows the radar reflectivity, Doppler velocity and vertically integrated liquid (VIL) measured from Monte Lema radar (marked with A in Fig. 1) at 17:30 UTC on August 20th, 2019."
Page 11 Line 265f: "Westerly flow is the most common flow situation in
Switzerland (MeteoSwiss, 2018b)"
Theoretically, you also show this in your own Figure 5b (even if only for 5 years). I would include the link here in addition to the citation.
If you have nothing to say about Figure 5c, then it is unnecessary for the publication. But if it is important to you, then write 1 or 2 sentences about it in the text.
Page 14 Line 310f: "At any given location"
Not quite clear to me, please rewrite or specify.