%PDF-1.5 % 17 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<0435381B991F4DA496CDE45613B1F116><22FDC9F7AB234C90B855DF5183A75681>]/Index[17 38]/Info 16 0 R/Length 86/Prev 89229/Root 18 0 R/Size 55/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream hbbd```b``"l% "5@7gGL@$Wg$9 hzF/0 5 endstream endobj startxref 0 %%EOF 54 0 obj <>stream hb```e``Ra`a`P] @1/a5XLoW{6 6F@"@YnabQBxz*Nƨ+ ) ` L# endstream endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <>/ExtGState<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/Type/Page>> endobj 20 0 obj <>stream hYo8 [^:"19y7<(6+K`갤ȉB&Dq87"HMGC8WD;0hDKI#Zq?G× .DIKT3W0뀪,<}TLjЮC4'-%\;dE$͆{ƹ+zf010zs[InnٳUSC~߃",]V/ݗzM1Yl?-6&)ޙmx>4xc1aVg3b6i4 Rtfʉ#\:mNI1V#ͤ. ̸ڃΣ@h]Ýi2 1xPdX?aҺb. '`t 2(8ˢ}fGrCN[rXjLl~_̮=Hgh!dtI+lP8TMi袍o:@fF]4HJ"dOxPA h8"" v , lj ߍ.z 8NQ;GC!hݪyGռw2Y0hgk]9կ4>JI5(ˋSջn',?jW1pr/W6Spm@̈́ GPrf5@ȶrUep>Dýʦ7cYaVKokKGҾu߭V{$Z2M/w#OXT{{G4I{T볐^{^kmsJ0SDRYEl5%kWb+X-~eKRZ^=OtY! "P ;A1?|}AsAW~,'Yao«@'.lU!?gS/R )og h` ct endstream endobj 21 0 obj <>stream H\Mj0:,EP]JJP'#Gb,/|U@$1zOWM>r &<91LlZ= ۴vyJc¡.#xͧ-nC~l)_졪a'L<AglW;}w¼9"r_E6ԣ*RRBroJ}Br|dzp=x3A9",' lo endstream endobj 22 0 obj <>stream BT /CS0 cs 0 0 0 scn /GS0 gs /TT0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 532.5399 75.36 Tm (1)Tj ( )Tj /C2_0 1 Tf 10.8 0 0 10.8 56.64 49.92 Tm <0001>Tj /TT1 1 Tf 0.083 Tw 12 0 0 12 56.64 759.6 Tm (Review on "Erosive phenomena in the Kaulon archaeological site: origins \ and remedies" by )Tj 0 Tw 0 -1.16 TD (Barbaro et al., Anonymous Referee # 2, 23 Mar 2017)Tj ( )Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0 -1.14 TD ( )Tj 0 -1.16 TD (GENERAL COMMENT)Tj (S)Tj ( )Tj 0 -1.14 TD ( )Tj 0.058 Tw 0 -1.16 TD (The paper describe)Tj (s the erosive phenomena occurring along the coast of Mones)Tj 32.491 0 Td (terace Marina \(Ca-)Tj 0.042 Tw -32.491 -1.14 Td (labria, Italy\) and)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj 0.042 Tw 7.011 0 Td (investigates on )Tj (possible causes of shoreline changes through the analysis of diffe-)Tj 0.021 Tw -7.011 -1.16 Td (rent types of data. In addition, a temporary)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj 0.021 Tw 17.497 0 Td (and a final solution to protect the Kaulon archaeological )Tj 0 Tw -17.497 -1.14 Td (site affected )Tj (by beach and dune er)Tj (o)Tj (sion )Tj (is proposed)Tj (. )Tj ( )Tj ET 1 1 1 scn 56.64 646.32 481.92 -13.68 re f BT 0 0 0 scn 0.042 Tw 12 0 0 12 56.64 635.28 Tm (In the present form, the paper)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj 0.042 Tw 12.33 0 Td (is redundant, verbous and)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj 0.042 Tw 10.693 0 Td (lacks a consistent scientific analysis and it )Tj ET 1 1 1 scn 56.64 632.88 238.56 -13.92 re f BT 0 0 0 scn 0.036 Tw 12 0 0 12 56.64 621.6 Tm (does not provide s)Tj (ubstantial and origina)Tj (l results; )Tj 0 Tw (t)Tj 0.036 Tw (here is a potentially very interesting )Tj 0 Tw (available )Tj 38.881 0 Td (da-)Tj 0.063 Tw -38.881 -1.16 Td (taset, but the paper could do with a more extensive)Tj 0 Tw 20.894 0 Td ( )Tj 0.313 0 Td (analysis)Tj ( )Tj 0.063 Tw 3.535 0 Td (by not including)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj 0.063 Tw 6.994 0 Td (previously published )Tj 0.031 Tw -31.735 -1.14 Td (material [)Tj 0 Tw (e.g. )Tj 0.031 Tw 5.615 0 Td (Barbaro, G., Foti, G., & Sicilia, C. L. \(2016\). Erosive Phenomena in t\ he Proxim)Tj (ity of)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj 0.02 Tw -5.615 -1.16 Td (Kaulon Archaeological Park: Origins and Remedies. Procedia)Tj 0 Tw (-)Tj 0.02 Tw (Social and Behavioral)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj 0.02 Tw 34.39 0 Td (Sciences, 223, )Tj 0 Tw -34.39 -1.14 Td (714)Tj (-)Tj (719])Tj (.)Tj ( )Tj 0.144 Tw 4.31 0 Td (As a consequence, t)Tj (he reviewer recommend)Tj 0 Tw (s)Tj ( )Tj 0.144 Tw 19.106 0 Td (reconsideration of the paper following )Tj 0 Tw (a )Tj -23.416 -1.16 Td (major revision. )Tj ( )Tj 0 -1.14 TD ( )Tj 0 -1.16 TD (DETAILED COMMENTS)Tj ( )Tj 0 -1.14 TD ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0 -1.24 TD (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 3, line 15:)Tj ( )Tj (sugges)Tj (t )Tj (to use)Tj ( )Tj (\223estimation\224 instead of \223calculation\224.)Tj 27.132 0 Td ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -28.632 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0.037 Tw 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 3, line 30: it seems redundant to consider an entire Section for li\ sting the main aims of the )Tj 0.106 Tw 0 -1.14 TD (paper. The objectives of the work can be briefly described in the introd\ uction)Tj 0 Tw 32.18 0 Td ( )Tj 0.106 Tw 0.356 0 Td (\(line 18 to fol-)Tj 0 Tw -32.536 -1.14 Td (low\). )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.24 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0.008 Tw 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 4, )Tj (line 12: suggest )Tj 0 Tw (to )Tj 0.008 Tw 10.602 0 Td (substitute \223Geographic\224 classification with \223Geographical\224 c\ lassifica-)Tj 0 Tw -10.602 -1.14 Td (tion. )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 7 to pag. 11: the quality of Figure 5 to 9 has to be improved. )Tj 26.357 0 Td ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -27.857 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 10, line 3: are you referring to the mean pe)Tj (ak wave period ? Please, explain)Tj (.)Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.24 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 11,)Tj ( )Tj (line )Tj (18: symbol \221)Tj (h)Tj (\222 has )Tj (not been )Tj (defined. )Tj ( )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 14, line 15: please, define )Tj /TT3 1 Tf (T)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 7.92 0 0 7.92 231.6068 365.5201 Tm (m)Tj 12 0 0 12 237.8295 366.96 Tm ( )Tj (as mean wave period. )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -15.099 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 15, Eq. \(16\): )Tj (please, explain the meaning of )Tj (\223per\224. )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 15, Figure 11: the quality of Figure 11 has to be improved. )Tj 25.719 0 Td ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -27.219 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0.122 Tw 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 16, line 3: \223The run)Tj 0 Tw (-)Tj (up )Tj 0.122 Tw 12.172 0 Td (has been calculated using a probabilistic based on the ETS mo-)Tj 0.062 Tw -12.172 -1.14 Td (del\205\224. D)Tj 0 Tw (o)Tj ( )Tj 0.062 Tw 4.761 0 Td (you mean \223The run)Tj 0 Tw (-)Tj 0.062 Tw (up has been calculated using a probabilistic approach based on )Tj 0 Tw -4.761 -1.14 Td (the ETS model\205\224 ? )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.24 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0.084 Tw 1.5 0 Td [(Pag. )0.5(16, )0.5(line )]TJ [(11: )0.5(Please, )0.5(define )0.5(\223X\224 )0.5(as )0.5(fixed )0.5(treshold. )0.5(Suggest )]TJ 0 Tw (to )Tj 0.084 Tw 26.997 0 Td [(change )0.5(the )0.5(sente)]TJ [(nce )0.5(\223Return )]TJ 0.067 Tw -26.997 -1.14 Td (period of a run)Tj 0 Tw (-)Tj 0.067 Tw (up level higher than a fixed treshold is determined as\205\224, with: \223\ Return period )Tj 0 Tw 0 -1.16 TD (of a run)Tj (-)Tj (up level higher than a fixed treshold, X, is determined as\205\224.)Tj 27.797 0 Td ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -29.297 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0.042 Tw 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 16, line 17: Please, define \223D\(X\) as the mean persistence of t\ he run)Tj 0 Tw 29.479 0 Td (-)Tj 0.042 Tw (up a)Tj (bove X\224. Suggest)Tj 0 Tw ( )Tj -29.479 -1.14 Td (to)Tj ( )Tj 0.102 Tw 1.13 0 Td (change the sentence \223The mean persistence of the run)Tj 0 Tw 22.308 0 Td (-)Tj 0.102 Tw (up above the fixed treshold is given )Tj 0 Tw -23.438 -1.16 Td (by\205\224 with: \223The mean persistence of the run)Tj 18.244 0 Td (-)Tj (up, D\(X\), above X is given by\205\224. )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -19.744 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 17, Figure 12: Please, add axes labels. )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 17, Figure 13: Pl)Tj (ease, add axes labels.)Tj ( )Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0.097 Tw 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 17, line 8: \223To evaluate changes in river sediment transport hyd\ raulic structures, ...\224. D)Tj 0 Tw 38.158 0 Td (o)Tj ( )Tj 0.022 Tw -38.158 -1.14 Td (you mean \223To evaluate changes in river sediment transport in presence\ of hydraulic structures,.. )Tj 0 Tw T* (\224 ?)Tj ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.5 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 17, line 12: suggest )Tj (to )Tj (subs)Tj (titute \223cards\224 with \223charts\224. )Tj 24.189 0 Td ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -25.689 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.5 0 Td (Pag. 18, line 3: suggest )Tj (to )Tj (substitute \223Land cover data\224 with \223Digital mapping\224.)Tj 31.91 0 Td ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf -33.41 -1.22 Td (\225)Tj /C2_1 1 Tf <0001>Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0.099 Tw 1.5 0 Td [(Pag. )0.5(20, )0.5(line )0.5(9: )0.5(\223where )0.5(h )0.5(is )0.5(the )0.5(average )0.5(yearly )0.5(temperature\224. )0.5(Please, )0.5(consider )0.5(that )0.5(symbol )0.5(\221)]TJ 0 Tw 37.825 0 Td (h)Tj (\222 )Tj ET endstream endobj 23 0 obj <>stream H\Aj0E>3N!Phgh8(")T`A93<WvNTU.]lےqhi@dgoMpg7H-xeЫMovFt^0-!ԥ~øqI![P5FEUH~P,w%ncjSʭ̒#ǚRL ~ԏ ao endstream endobj 24 0 obj <>stream HQMkQ=|$fB+3MZZҴ)Ґ b-ԦM`%PFE B3Bi UG3Uǻs>.wfΫJPp7G\%:%{E52 PZ{*:mU{{3?SoWKo 7\"iLQbr*9όdI%5kSOO&Uroo2{[NK)Ybf_lv8R3\RљKkΕ䁢[F܊jԊ_%}(it\]zT&D_`a9OFDW]fѝ./yio?GWrOW;mIf. { uP˟bFm_|L@(OFs zEULк=v˄Lr1D 3I`feOxv*qK41" X8!*XEM-RluG N endstream endobj 25 0 obj <>stream H: ` endstream endobj 26 0 obj <>stream H: ` endstream endobj 27 0 obj <>stream HOMKQ=fDȅB(T PDƔeQ']*Zoh\.s}02ت{'3f:[kv\m*~1C(rmُď+T*= MDXh$;0x@][|X1s^֓>ƃ ct.0,ԔF,S;S;B ;:0{'D_&p`(Ʈ>bHJ,$V%ֈv*lx,-P@)dA<9 .9gg[ HU} endstream endobj 28 0 obj <>stream HyTSwoɞc [5laQIBHADED2mtFOE.c}088GNg9w߽ '0 ֠Jb 2y.-;!KZ ^i"L0- @8(r;q7Ly&Qq4j|9 V)gB0iW8#8wթ8_٥ʨQQj@&A)/g>'K t;\ ӥ$պFZUn(4T%)뫔0C&Zi8bxEB;Pӓ̹Aom?W= x- [ 0}y)7ta>jT7@tܛ`q2ʀ&6ZLĄ?_yxg)˔zçLU*uSkSeO4?c. R ߁-25 S>ӣVd`rn~Y&+`;A4 A9 =-tl`;~p Gp| [`L`< "AYA+Cb(R, *T2B- ꇆnQt}MA0alSx k&^>0|>_',G!"F$H:R!zFQd?r9\A&GrQhE]a4zBgE#H *B=0HIpp0MxJ$D1D, VĭKĻYdE"EI2EBGt4MzNr!YK ?%_(0J:EAiQ(()ӔWT6U@P+!~mDeԴ!hӦh/']B/ҏӿ?a0nhF!X8܌kc&5S6lIa2cKMA!E#ƒdV(kel }}Cq9 N')].uJr wG xR^[oƜchg`>b$*~ :Eb~,m,-ݖ,Y¬*6X[ݱF=3뭷Y~dó tizf6~`{v.Ng#{}}jc1X6fm;'_9 r:8q:˜O:ϸ8uJqnv=MmR 4 n3ܣkGݯz=[==<=GTB(/S,]6*-W:#7*e^YDY}UjAyT`#D="b{ų+ʯ:!kJ4Gmt}uC%K7YVfFY.=b?SƕƩȺy چk5%4m7lqlioZlG+Zzmzy]?uuw|"űNwW&e֥ﺱ*|j5kyݭǯg^ykEklD_p߶7Dmo꿻1ml{Mś nLl<9O [$h՛BdҞ@iءG&vVǥ8nRĩ7u\ЭD- u`ֲK³8%yhYѹJº;.! zpg_XQKFAǿ=ȼ:ɹ8ʷ6˶5̵5͵6ζ7ϸ9к<Ѿ?DINU\dlvۀ܊ݖޢ)߯6DScs 2F[p(@Xr4Pm8Ww)Km endstream endobj 29 0 obj <>stream HV{tMW~{s/+^WH$W(!f)!(TYQF="tUQPo Kc1FY{Ycf{ηY{{^Y3fC#~R^Z>^>_mҜYC8fg$vif'w/JO|yʼnJj7knոGN} ?ƼU_iyU|EO9j\סU{6P;BpZj6 oj rMMBmA]C M8n=-ۆPUg@kTʹE$шA{t@GĢ:=:z}D??IB_$Xӟ_6 l:' }9WU zlJ{GwE/ :YOyr1uk*r&\x-\gDRpMqn.)XfS*>ߋ#+$Hi˓W2F>69ڂ[ʔ-YEX\W9Y0Ų@2/RQhZF .H {1Ͼ\ rjI0[KΝ2jeN1Ư?/u 7}&jNіNo\Ilai/U #m5v8#)2Vizmy5܊c
".ʺ]eLY-\+ʡBtuO{)ٶMwjTyg,F`! &Q"?QU"Ckz^m=],'c$2ЛFԡLI?Pֵt֝to=B:{5*4ę;kR{3z!blBXw/k %s|?1uKdI>crBN yjIDΪJPI*S-!֩3ꢺIz^L˲݁Hb)g39hbk>~[;mFy?`)I|L