Interactive discussionStatus: closed
AC: Author comment | RC: Referee comment | SC: Short comment | EC: Editor comment | : Report abuse
Printer-friendly Version - Printer-friendly version      Supplement - Supplement
 
SC1: 'Welcome commentary: commentary is not enough, need to present an alternative way forward', Murugesu Sivapalan, 12 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC1: 'Response to Prof. Sivapalan', Maik Heistermann, 24 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
RC1: 'Referee Report', Anonymous Referee #1, 22 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC2: 'Response to referee #1', Maik Heistermann, 24 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
SC2: 'Quantitative concerns on the concept of Planetary Boundaries on Freshwater', Christof Lorenz, 22 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC3: 'Response to Dr Lorenz', Maik Heistermann, 24 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
SC3: 'Check the freshwater planetary boundary debate', Fernando Jaramillo, 25 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC4: 'Response to Dr Jaramillo', Maik Heistermann, 27 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
RC2: 'A feedback mechanism is missing', Hubert H.G. Savenije, 26 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC5: 'Response to Prof Savanije', Maik Heistermann, 28 Mar 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
RC3: 'Review of opinion paper on freshwater planetary boundary', Dieter Gerten, 09 Apr 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC6: 'Response to Prof. Gerten', Maik Heistermann, 12 Apr 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
SC4: 'How significant is feedback?', Chris Perry, 14 Apr 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC7: 'Response to Dr Perry', Maik Heistermann, 20 Apr 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
SC5: 'Freshwater is a planetary boundary operating across scales', Johan Rockström, 02 May 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
AC8: 'Response to Prof. Rockström', Maik Heistermann, 05 May 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
AC9: 'Synopsis and suggested changes', Maik Heistermann, 05 May 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
 
AC10: 'Addendum to AC9: explicit is better than implicit...', Maik Heistermann, 22 May 2017 Printer-friendly Version 
Peer review completion
AR: Author's response | RR: Referee report | ED: Editor decision
ED: Publish subject to minor revisions (further review by Editor) (26 May 2017) by Erwin Zehe  
AR by Anna Mirena Feist-Polner on behalf of the Authors (08 Jun 2017)  Author's response
ED: Publish as is (09 Jun 2017) by Erwin Zehe